Skip to content

The Saint Files / Case SF-006

Draft: awaiting research review. Claims are not yet checked against their sources.

The Saint Files · Case no. SF-006

Prototype file

Subject · Apostle

Saint Andrew the Apostle

Home
Bethsaida in GalileeDocumentedC01
Trade
FishermanDocumentedC01
Brother
Simon PeterDocumentedC01
Before Jesus
Disciple of John the BaptistDocumentedC02
Death
Crucified at Patras (tradition)TraditionC09
Feast
November 30DocumentedC13

BLUF

Bottom Line Up Front

Case officer’s summary

Andrew was a fisherman from Galilee and a disciple of John the Baptist who became one of the first followers of Jesus. The Gospels show him again and again bringing people to Christ, starting with his own brother, Simon Peter. Tradition says he carried the Gospel to the Greek world and was crucified at Patras.1

His calling and his acts as an apostle come from the Gospels. His later missions and his martyrdom come from tradition, and the historical evidence for the shape of his cross is uncertain.

File section 01

The Brief

Historical record

Andrew was standing with John the Baptist by the Jordan when John pointed to Jesus and said, "Behold the Lamb of God" (John 1:36, Douay-Rheims). Andrew followed Jesus and spent the day with him.2

The first thing he did afterward was find his brother Simon and tell him that they had found the Messiah (John 1:41). He brought Simon to Jesus, and Jesus gave Simon a new name: Peter.3

Notes & Evidence(3)
    • Documented — Home, trade and family. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C01
    • Documented — Disciple of the Baptist. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C02
    • Documented — Brought Simon to Jesus. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C03
    • Tradition — Missions. Eusebius, Church History and 2 more. C08
    • Tradition — Crucifixion at Patras. Benedict XVI, General Audience, 14 June 2006 ("Andrew, the Protoclete") and 2 more. C09
    ↩
    • Documented — Disciple of the Baptist. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C02
    ↩
    • Documented — Brought Simon to Jesus. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C03
    ↩
File section 02

The Full File

Historical record

Scripture · Gospels

What the Gospels record

Andrew and his brother Simon were fishermen from Bethsaida in Galilee. Before he met Jesus, Andrew was a disciple of John the Baptist.4

John's Gospel tells how John the Baptist pointed Jesus out to two of his disciples, and Andrew was one of them. They followed Jesus and stayed with him that day. Andrew then told his brother Simon that they had found the Messiah (John 1:41), and brought him to Jesus.5

Matthew's Gospel tells the calling another way: Jesus saw Simon and Andrew casting a net into the Sea of Galilee and said, "Come ye after me, and I will make you to be fishers of men" (Matthew 4:19, Douay-Rheims). Both brothers immediately gave up their work with the nets to follow Jesus (Matthew 4:20). Andrew is named among the Twelve.6

John's Gospel shows him twice more bringing others to Jesus. Before the feeding of the five thousand, it was Andrew who pointed out a boy with five barley loaves and two fish (John 6:9). Later, when some Greeks asked to see Jesus, Andrew and Philip brought the request to him.7

Tradition · early Christian writers and later accounts

The mission and the cross

The New Testament does not say where Andrew went after Pentecost. The church historian Eusebius, passing on what Origen had written, records the tradition that Andrew's mission field was Scythia, the lands north of the Black Sea. Pope Benedict XVI spoke of ancient traditions that he preached the Gospel in the Greek world.8

Tradition says Andrew was crucified at Patras, in Greece. Accounts differ on the details: the 1907 Catholic Encyclopedia reports that he was bound to his cross rather than nailed, while Benedict XVI described him as nailed.9

Christian art often shows Andrew on an X-shaped cross. A later tradition identifies this as the shape of his cross, and the historical evidence for its shape is uncertain.10

Historical record · open questions

Where the evidence runs out

The New Testament last names Andrew among the apostles gathered in Jerusalem after the Ascension. The year of his death and his age are uncertain.11

The 1907 Catholic Encyclopedia found no certainty about where he worked, and judged that the evidence for the shape of his cross seems to be no older than the fourteenth century.12

Historical record · 4th, 13th and 20th centuries

His relics

According to the 1907 Catholic Encyclopedia, his relics were carried from Patras to Constantinople around the year 357. The same source says that after crusaders took Constantinople in the early thirteenth century, Cardinal Peter of Capua brought them to Italy, where most remained in the cathedral of Amalfi.13

Patras received back an important relic of Saint Andrew in 1964, when Pope Paul VI gave it to the Orthodox Metropolitan of Patras; it had been kept until then in Saint Peter's Basilica.14

Liturgy

In the Church today

Both the Latin and Greek Churches keep his feast on November 30. In the Roman calendar, Advent begins on the Sunday nearest November 30, starting with Evening Prayer I of that Sunday (Universal Norms, §40), so the new liturgical year starts near his feast.15

Notes & Evidence(12)
    • Documented — Home, trade and family. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C01
    • Documented — Disciple of the Baptist. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C02
    ↩
    • Documented — Disciple of the Baptist. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C02
    • Documented — Brought Simon to Jesus. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C03
    ↩
    • Documented — Called at the Sea of Galilee. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C04
    • Documented — One of the Twelve. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C05
    ↩
    • Documented — The loaves and fish. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C06
    • Documented — The Greeks. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C07
    ↩
    • Tradition — Missions. Eusebius, Church History and 2 more. C08
    ↩
    • Tradition — Crucifixion at Patras. Benedict XVI, General Audience, 14 June 2006 ("Andrew, the Protoclete") and 2 more. C09
    ↩
    • Tradition — The X-shaped cross. Vatican News, "St. Andrew, Apostle" and 2 more. C10
    ↩
    • Documented — One of the Twelve. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C05
    • Unknown — Date of death. Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), "St. Andrew". C15
    ↩
    • Tradition — Missions. Eusebius, Church History and 2 more. C08
    • Tradition — The X-shaped cross. Vatican News, "St. Andrew, Apostle" and 2 more. C10
    ↩
    • Documented — Relics to Constantinople. Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), "St. Andrew". C11
    • Documented — Relics to Amalfi. Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), "St. Andrew". C12
    ↩
    • Documented — Relic returned to Patras. Benedict XVI, General Audience, 14 June 2006 ("Andrew, the Protoclete"). C16
    ↩
    • Documented — Feast. Vatican City State, "30 November: Saint Andrew the Apostle" and 2 more. C13
    • Documented — Advent. Universal Norms on the Liturgical Year and the Calendar and 1 more. C14
    ↩
File section 03

Why He Matters

Editorial reflection

Andrew is the apostle who keeps bringing people to Jesus. The first thing he did after meeting Christ was go and get his brother. Later he noticed a boy with a small lunch, and he took a request from strangers seriously enough to pass it on.

None of that took a big platform. At Pentecost it was Peter who stood up and spoke to the crowd. Andrew's gift was noticing people and making introductions.

For a young Catholic, that is a reachable kind of holiness: inviting a friend, pointing someone toward help, telling a brother or sister what you have found.

Who in your life could you bring a little closer to Christ this week, just by inviting them?

Virtues
Zeal · Humility · Generosity
Popularly invoked as patron of
Scotland · Russia · Romania · Ukraine
File section 04

Intel Assessment

Historical record

Andrew's calling and his place among the Twelve are recorded in the Gospels. Everything after the Gospels, including where he preached and how he died, rests on tradition, and the traditions differ on details. The historical evidence for the shape of his cross is uncertain. His feast and the start of Advent are fixed by the liturgy; the history of his relics is reported but still being checked.

Key judgments

  1. Fisherman, disciple of the Baptist, apostleHigh confidence

    Recorded in more than one Gospel.

    DocumentedC01DocumentedC02DocumentedC03DocumentedC04DocumentedC05DocumentedC06DocumentedC07

  2. Missions after PentecostLimited historical corroboration

    Early writers name different regions; the Catholic Encyclopedia finds no certainty. This limitation concerns the available historical documentation; it is not a judgment against the tradition itself or its place in Catholic devotion.

    TraditionC08

  3. Crucifixion at PatrasLimited historical corroboration

    A long and widely held tradition, not attested in the New Testament. This limitation concerns the available historical documentation; it is not a judgment against the tradition itself.

    TraditionC09

  4. The X-shaped crossUnresolved

    A later tradition, retold by Vatican News and framed as tradition by Benedict XVI. The 1907 Catholic Encyclopedia judged the evidence for the shape to be no older than the fourteenth century.

    TraditionC10

  5. Feast and AdventHigh confidence

    Fixed in the current liturgical norms and calendars.

    DocumentedC13DocumentedC14

  6. RelicsModerate confidence

    The fourth- and thirteenth-century transfers are reported by the Catholic Encyclopedia; the early records and current custody still need checking. The 1964 return is recorded by Benedict XVI.

    DocumentedC11DocumentedC12DocumentedC16

High confidence
Multiple early or independent sources agree.
Moderate confidence
Early and credible, but single-sourced or uncorroborated.
Limited historical corroboration
Rests on later sources only. Cannot be confirmed or ruled out. Not a verdict against tradition.
Unresolved
The evidence conflicts or is absent.

Claims register

Documented: 12Tradition: 3Disputed: 0Unknown: 1

C02Disciple of the BaptistDocumented

Andrew was a disciple of John the Baptist and followed Jesus after John pointed him out as the Lamb of God.

The quotation from John 1:36 follows the Douay-Rheims, 1899 American Edition.

C03Brought Simon to JesusDocumented

Andrew told his brother Simon that they had found the Messiah (John 1:41), and brought him to Jesus.

C04Called at the Sea of GalileeDocumented

Jesus called Simon and Andrew while they were casting a net into the Sea of Galilee, promising to make them fishers of men.

C06The loaves and fishDocumented

Before the feeding of the five thousand, Andrew told Jesus of a boy with five barley loaves and two fish (John 6:9).

C11Relics to ConstantinopleDocumented

His relics were translated from Patras to Constantinople around 357.

Identify the primary record for the translation.

C12Relics to AmalfiDocumented

After the capture of Constantinople in the early thirteenth century, Cardinal Peter of Capua brought most of his relics to Amalfi, where they remain in the cathedral.

C08MissionsTradition

Eusebius, citing Origen, transmits the tradition that Andrew's mission field was Scythia; Benedict XVI speaks of ancient traditions of his preaching in the Greek world.

The Catholic Encyclopedia also attributes Epirus (Gregory Nazianzen), Achaia (Jerome) and Hellas (Theodoret); these are kept out of the narrative until the original passages are located.

C09Crucifixion at PatrasTradition

Tradition says Andrew was crucified at Patras.

The earliest surviving Patras witness is open while the individual texts of the apocryphal Acts of Andrew are checked. Details differ: the Catholic Encyclopedia says he was bound rather than nailed (by order of the governor Aegeas); Benedict XVI says he was nailed. The narrative attributes each.

C10The X-shaped crossTradition

A later tradition identifies Andrew's cross as X-shaped; the historical evidence for its shape is uncertain.

Reclassified from disputed to tradition with unresolved confidence. The Catholic Encyclopedia's estimate (evidence no older than the fourteenth century) concerns the evidence for the shape.

File section 05

Sources

Historical record

Cited in this file

  1. Early source1899Draft

    The Holy Bible, Douay-Rheims Version, American Edition (1899). Online (opens in a new tab)

    Shared record for Scripture citations.

  2. Reference work1907Draft

    Joseph MacRory, "St. Andrew," in The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 1 (New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907). Online (opens in a new tab)

    Finds no certainty about his missions; says the evidence for the X-shaped cross seems no older than the fourteenth century; relics to Constantinople c. 357 and to Amalfi in the thirteenth century; Russia and Scotland honour him as chief patron.

  3. Early sourceearly 4th centuryDraft

    Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History (Ecclesiastical History), 3.1.1–3. Online (opens in a new tab)

    At 3.1 Eusebius records, citing Origen, the tradition of the apostles' mission fields, assigning Scythia to Andrew. Shared record; other dossiers may cite other books.

  4. Early source2006Draft

    Benedict XVI, General Audience, "Andrew, the Protoclete," 14 June 2006. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Speaks of ancient traditions of Andrew's preaching in the Greek world; calls his crucifixion at Patras tradition and describes him as nailed to an X-shaped cross; records Paul VI's 1964 return of an important relic to the Orthodox Metropolitan of Patras.

  5. HagiographyDraft

    Acts of Andrew (apocryphal), as catalogued in the e-Clavis: Christian Apocrypha. Online (opens in a new tab)

  6. Reference workDraft

    Vatican News, "St. Andrew, Apostle," Saint of the Day, 30 November. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Calls him the first apostle called by Jesus, patron of the Church of Constantinople, martyred on a diagonal cross; says early Christian writers place his preaching in Asia Minor and along the Black Sea; names Romania, Ukraine and Russia as patronages.

  7. Reference workDraft

    Vatican City State, "30 November: Saint Andrew the Apostle," Saint of the Day. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Feast 30 November; presents Andrew as one of the two disciples of John the Baptist who followed Jesus (John 1:35-39).

  8. Liturgical1969Draft

    Universal Norms on the Liturgical Year and the General Roman Calendar (1969), §40. Online (opens in a new tab)

    §40 sets the start of Advent at Evening Prayer I of the Sunday that falls on or closest to 30 November. Shared record for liturgical-season claims.

  9. Reference work1907Draft

    Francis Mershman, "Advent," in The Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 1 (New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907). Online (opens in a new tab)

    Describes Advent, according to present usage, as beginning with the Sunday nearest the feast of St. Andrew (30 November). Interim source until the current liturgical norms are cited.