Skip to content

The Saint Files / Case SF-019

Draft: awaiting research review. Claims are not yet checked against their sources.

The Saint Files · Case no. SF-019

Prototype file

Subject · Apostle

Saint Peter the Apostle

From
Bethsaida, GalileeDocumentedC01
Trade
FishermanDocumentedC01
Family
Brother of Andrew; marriedDocumentedC02
Died
Rome, under Nero (early Christian testimony)DocumentedC13
Feasts
29 June (with Paul); 22 February, Chair of Saint PeterDocumentedC17
Patron of
Rome (with Saint Paul)DocumentedC20

BLUF

Bottom Line Up Front

Case officer’s summary

Simon Peter was a fisherman from Galilee whom Jesus called and renamed "Rock." The Gospels name him first of the Twelve and show him confessing Jesus as the Christ, then denying him. After the Resurrection he led the first Christians. Scripture does not record his death; early Christian writers place his martyrdom in Rome.1

John's Gospel alludes to his death. 1 Clement remembers his martyrdom without naming the place; later writers name Rome and Nero. That he was crucified head downward is early Christian tradition.

File section 01

The Brief

Historical record

Simon, a fisherman from Bethsaida and brother of Andrew, left his nets when Jesus called him. Jesus named him Cephas, Peter, "rock." He confessed Jesus as the Christ, denied him three times on the night of his arrest, and wept.2

The risen Jesus appeared to him and charged him to feed his sheep. In the Acts of the Apostles he preaches at Pentecost, welcomes the first Gentile converts and speaks at the council in Jerusalem. Early Christian writers place his martyrdom in Rome.3

Notes & Evidence(3)
    • Documented — Origin and trade. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C01
    • Documented — The name Peter. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C04
    • Documented — First of the Twelve. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C05
    • Documented — Confession and the keys. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C06
    • Documented — Denial and repentance. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C08
    • Documented — Feed my sheep. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C10
    • Documented — Leader of the first community. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C11
    • Documented — Rome and Nero. Eusebius, Church History and 2 more. C13
    • Documented — Martyrdom remembered. 1 Clement (Letter of Clement to the Corinthians). C14
    • Documented — Crucified head downward. Eusebius, Church History. C15
    ↩
    • Documented — Origin and trade. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C01
    • Documented — The call. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C03
    • Documented — The name Peter. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C04
    • Documented — Confession and the keys. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C06
    • Documented — Denial and repentance. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C08
    ↩
    • Documented — Witness of the Resurrection. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C09
    • Documented — Feed my sheep. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C10
    • Documented — Leader of the first community. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C11
    • Documented — Rome and Nero. Eusebius, Church History and 2 more. C13
    • Documented — Martyrdom remembered. 1 Clement (Letter of Clement to the Corinthians). C14
    ↩
File section 02

The Full File

Historical record

Scripture · the Gospels

The fisherman

Simon came from Bethsaida, by the Sea of Galilee, and fished there with his brother Andrew. He was married; when Jesus visited his house in Capernaum, he healed Simon's mother-in-law of a fever.4

In Mark's Gospel Jesus called the brothers from their nets: "Come after me, and I will make you to become fishers of men" (Mark 1:17, Douay-Rheims). Luke tells it on the lake after a great catch of fish: Simon fell at Jesus' knees, and Jesus told him, "Fear not: from henceforth thou shalt catch men" (Luke 5:10, Douay-Rheims).5

Jesus gave him a new name, Cephas, an Aramaic word for rock; in Greek it is Petros, Peter. Matthew names him first in the list of the Twelve.6

Scripture · the Gospels

The rock and the stumbling

Near Caesarea Philippi, when Jesus asked, "But whom do you say that I am?" (Matthew 16:15, Douay-Rheims), Simon Peter answered, "Thou art Christ, the Son of the living God" (Matthew 16:16, Douay-Rheims). Jesus told him "thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church" (Matthew 16:18, Douay-Rheims), and promised him the keys of the kingdom of heaven.7

He was bold and impulsive. Matthew tells how he stepped out of the boat to walk to Jesus on the water, then grew frightened and began to sink, crying, "Lord, save me" (Matthew 14:30, Douay-Rheims).8

On the night Jesus was arrested, Peter followed him to the high priest's courtyard and three times denied knowing him. When the cock crowed, he remembered Jesus' words and wept bitterly (Matthew 26:75).9

Scripture · Resurrection and Acts

Feed my sheep

Paul names Cephas first in his list of those to whom the risen Christ appeared. By the Sea of Galilee, John's Gospel says, three times Jesus asked about Peter's love and entrusted his flock to him. John adds words of Jesus that point to the death by which Peter would glorify God.10

In the Acts of the Apostles, Peter preaches to the crowds at Pentecost, orders the baptism of the Roman centurion Cornelius and his household, the first Gentile converts, and speaks for their acceptance at the council in Jerusalem.11

He was not beyond correction. Paul writes that at Antioch he "withstood him to the face" (Galatians 2:11, Douay-Rheims) when Peter stopped eating with Gentile Christians.12

Church teaching · Catechism

The Church's teaching

The Church understands Christ's giving Peter the keys and entrusting the flock to him as a commission to shepherd the whole Church.13

Tradition · early Christian writers

Rome

The New Testament does not describe Peter's journey to Rome or his death. The letter known as 1 Clement, written from Rome in the late first century, recalls that Peter "endured not one or two, but numerous labours" and bore witness; it does not say where or how he died.14

Dionysius, bishop of Corinth around 170, wrote that Peter and Paul taught together in Italy and suffered martyrdom at the same time; his words survive because the historian Eusebius quoted them. Eusebius himself records that Peter was crucified in Rome under the emperor Nero.15

Early Christian tradition adds that Peter was crucified head downward at his own request. Eusebius reports this from Origen.16

Tradition · the Roman memorial

The tomb

At the end of the second century a Roman priest named Gaius wrote that he could show "the trophies of the apostles" on the Vatican and on the Ostian Way. A small shrine built on the Vatican hill, known as the Trophy of Gaius, lies beneath the main altar of Saint Peter's Basilica.17

Historical record · archaeology

The excavations

Archaeologists excavated beneath the basilica from 1939 to 1949. In 1968 Pope Paul VI said that relics of Peter had been identified in a way that could be regarded as convincing, and that research and discussion would continue.18

The Church celebrates Peter with Paul on 29 June, and the Chair of Saint Peter on 22 February. Pope Leo XIV calls Peter and Paul the patrons of Rome.19

Notes & Evidence(16)
    • Documented — Origin and trade. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C01
    • Documented — Marriage. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C02
    ↩
    • Documented — The call. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C03
    ↩
    • Documented — The name Peter. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C04
    • Documented — First of the Twelve. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C05
    ↩
    • Documented — Confession and the keys. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C06
    ↩
    • Documented — Walking on the water. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition. C07
    ↩
    • Documented — Denial and repentance. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C08
    ↩
    • Documented — Witness of the Resurrection. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C09
    • Documented — Feed my sheep. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C10
    ↩
    • Documented — Leader of the first community. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C11
    ↩
    • Documented — Correction at Antioch. Douay-Rheims Bible, 1899 American Edition and 1 more. C12
    ↩
    • Documented — Church teaching. Catechism of the Catholic Church. C18
    ↩
    • Documented — Martyrdom remembered. 1 Clement (Letter of Clement to the Corinthians). C14
    ↩
    • Documented — Rome and Nero. Eusebius, Church History and 2 more. C13
    ↩
    • Documented — Crucified head downward. Eusebius, Church History. C15
    ↩
    • Documented — The ancient memorial. Eusebius, Church History and 1 more. C16
    ↩
    • Documented — Excavations and relics. Saint Peter's Basilica, "The Tomb of Saint Peter" and 1 more. C19
    ↩
    • Documented — Feasts. General Roman Calendar. C17
    • Documented — Patron of Rome. Leo XIV, Angelus, Solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul (29 June 2026). C20
    ↩
File section 03

Why He Matters

Editorial reflection

The Gospels do not hide Peter's failures. He says the right thing about Jesus and then the wrong thing; he walks on water and then sinks; he swears he will never leave Jesus and then denies him three times.

After the denial, Peter wept. When the risen Jesus met him by the lake, he asked about Peter's love three times and entrusted his flock to him.

The man who had been afraid in a courtyard later preached to crowds, and the early Church remembered that he died for Christ.

When you have let someone down, what would it look like to come back the way Peter did?

Virtues
Faith · Courage · Repentance · Leadership
Struggles
Fear · Failure · Impulsiveness
Patron of
Rome (with Saint Paul)
Interests
Fishing
Careers
Fishing
File section 04

Intel Assessment

Historical record

Peter's call, his place among the Twelve, his confession, his denial and his leadership in the first community are recorded throughout the New Testament. His death in Rome is not in Scripture but rests on early Christian testimony. 1 Clement recalls Peter's suffering and witness. Dionysius links Peter and Paul to the churches of Rome and Corinth and recalls their martyrdom. Eusebius places Peter's crucifixion in Rome under Nero. The head-down crucifixion is later tradition; the 1968 identification of relics was presented as convincing, not final.

Key judgments

  1. Peter in the New TestamentHigh confidence

    The passages are in the canonical text. This file documents what they say.

    DocumentedC01DocumentedC03DocumentedC04DocumentedC05DocumentedC06DocumentedC08DocumentedC09DocumentedC10DocumentedC11DocumentedC12

  2. Martyrdom in RomeHigh confidence

    Not in Scripture, but early and consistent. 1 Clement recalls Peter's suffering and witness. Dionysius of Corinth (around 170) links Peter and Paul to the churches of Rome and Corinth and recalls their martyrdom. Eusebius places Peter's crucifixion in Rome under Nero. Gaius points to the Vatican memorial.

    DocumentedC13DocumentedC14DocumentedC16

  3. Crucified head downwardLimited historical corroboration

    Early Christian tradition, reported by Origen through Eusebius and told in the apocryphal Acts of Peter; no eyewitness testimony.

    DocumentedC15

  4. His relicsModerate confidence

    Paul VI judged the identification could be regarded as convincing in 1968 but did not close the question.

    DocumentedC19

High confidence
Multiple early or independent sources agree.
Moderate confidence
Early and credible, but single-sourced or uncorroborated.
Limited historical corroboration
Rests on later sources only. Cannot be confirmed or ruled out. Not a verdict against tradition.
Unresolved
The evidence conflicts or is absent.

Claims register

Documented: 20Tradition: 0Disputed: 0Unknown: 0

C03The callDocumented

In Mark, Jesus called Simon and Andrew from their nets to be "fishers of men" (Mark 1:17, Douay-Rheims); in Luke, after a great catch on the lake, he told Simon, "Fear not: from henceforth thou shalt catch men" (Luke 5:10, Douay-Rheims).

The two settings are kept distinct. Quotations follow the Douay-Rheims, 1899 American Edition.

C06Confession and the keysDocumented

At Caesarea Philippi Peter confessed Jesus as "Christ, the Son of the living God" (Matthew 16:16, Douay-Rheims); Jesus told him "thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church" (Matthew 16:18, Douay-Rheims), and promised him the keys of the kingdom of heaven.

For the Church's teaching on Peter's office, see the Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§552–553 and §§880–882.

C07Walking on the waterDocumented

Peter walked on the water toward Jesus, became frightened, began to sink and cried, "Lord, save me" (Matthew 14:30, Douay-Rheims).

C13Rome and NeroDocumented

Dionysius of Corinth (bishop until about 170), quoted by Eusebius, links the planting of Peter and Paul at Rome and Corinth and says they taught together in Italy and suffered martyrdom at the same time; Eusebius himself records that Peter was crucified in Rome under Nero. Benedict XVI says Peter travelled from Jerusalem through Antioch to Rome.

Each witness named with who preserves the quotation. Not in the New Testament; 1 Peter 5:13 ("Babylon") not used.

C14Martyrdom rememberedDocumented

1 Clement, written from Rome in the late first century, recalls Peter's many labours and his witness; it does not give the place, emperor or manner of his death.

"late first century" is the conventional dating; no single year is asserted.

C15Crucified head downwardDocumented

Eusebius reports Origen's account that Peter, coming to Rome, was crucified head downward at his own request.

The attribution is documented; wherever the reader sees the event itself it is labelled early Christian tradition. The apocryphal Acts of Peter also tells the story (not catalogued here); multiple tellings are not independent eyewitness testimony.

C16The ancient memorialDocumented

Gaius, a Roman priest at the end of the second century, quoted by Eusebius, pointed to "the trophies of the apostles" on the Vatican and the Ostian Way; the aedicule known as the Trophy of Gaius lies beneath the main altar of Saint Peter's Basilica.

Date from the basilica's page. Benedict XVI (4 February 2009) says early second century; Eusebius II.25.6 places Gaius under Bishop Zephyrinus. "Around AD 200" if a single date is wanted.

C17FeastsDocumented

The General Roman Calendar keeps Saints Peter and Paul on 29 June (solemnity) and the Chair of Saint Peter on 22 February (feast).

C18Church teachingDocumented

The Catechism teaches that Simon Peter holds the first place in the college of the Twelve, and that the "power of the keys" (Catechism of the Catholic Church, §553) and the charge "Feed my sheep" (John 21:17, Douay-Rheims) designate authority to govern the Church.

The Catechism discusses the keys and Peter's confession in §§552–553 and the ministry of Peter and his successors in §§880–882.

C19Excavations and relicsDocumented

Excavations beneath the basilica took place from 1939 to 1949. On 26 June 1968 Paul VI said the relics of Saint Peter had been identified "in modo che possiamo ritenere convincente" (in a way that we can consider convincing; our translation) and that research and discussion would continue.

Paraphrased from the Italian original, which is milder than the EWTN English.

File section 05

Sources

Historical record

Cited in this file

  1. Early source1899Draft

    The Holy Bible, Douay-Rheims Version, American Edition (1899). Online (opens in a new tab)

    Shared record for Scripture citations.

  2. Early source2006Draft

    Pope Benedict XVI, General Audience, catechesis on the Apostles: "Peter, the fisherman," Saint Peter's Square, 17 May 2006. Online (opens in a new tab)

    From Bethsaida; fisherman with Andrew and the Zebedee family on the Lake of Gennesaret; married, mother-in-law at Capernaum; Simon (Symeon), Cephas, Petros; call after the catch (Luke 5:10); one of the first four disciples; confession at Caesarea Philippi.

  3. Early source1997Draft

    Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. (Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997).

    Shared record. §1014 asks Joseph, as patron of a happy death, to pray for us (cited in Patris corde, n. 5).

  4. Early source2006Draft

    Pope Benedict XVI, General Audience, catechesis on the Apostles: "Peter, the Apostle," Saint Peter's Square, 24 May 2006. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Confession "You are the Christ"; protest at the prophecy of the Cross; denial and "liberating repentance"; the threefold "Do you love me?" (John 21); Peter as "rock" of the Church.

  5. Early source2006Draft

    Pope Benedict XVI, General Audience, catechesis on the Apostles (third on Peter), Saint Peter's Square, 7 June 2006. Online (opens in a new tab)

    First witness of an appearance of the Risen One (Luke 24:34; 1 Cor 15:5); pre-eminence in Acts 1–10; criticism (Acts 11; Gal 2); directive role at the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15). Exact title to confirm from the Holy See page.

  6. Early sourceearly 4th centuryDraft

    Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History (Ecclesiastical History), 3.1.1–3. Online (opens in a new tab)

    At 3.1 Eusebius records, citing Origen, the tradition of the apostles' mission fields, assigning Scythia to Andrew. Shared record; other dossiers may cite other books.

  7. Reference workDraft

    Philip Schaff, History of the Christian Church, vol. 2: Ante-Nicene Christianity, A.D. 100–325. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Dates Dionysius of Corinth "in the third quarter of the second century, till about a.d. 170." Edition and date of this printing to confirm.

  8. Early source2006Draft

    Benedict XVI, General Audience, "Andrew, the Protoclete," 14 June 2006. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Speaks of ancient traditions of Andrew's preaching in the Greek world; calls his crucifixion at Patras tradition and describes him as nailed to an X-shaped cross; records Paul VI's 1964 return of an important relic to the Orthodox Metropolitan of Patras.

  9. Early sourceDraft

    Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians (1 Clement), tr. John Keith, in Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 9, ed. Allan Menzies. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Ch. 5: "Peter, through unrighteous envy, endured not one or two, but numerous labours," and departed to the place of glory; does not name place or manner of death. Usual dating about 96 to be sourced. If a shared record already exists, use it and add the Peter subject.

  10. Reference workDraft

    Fabbrica di San Pietro, "The Tomb of Saint Peter," basilicasanpietro.va. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Tomb beneath the main altar; aedicule "recorded by the priest Gaius at the end of the second century," generally called the Trophy of Gaius; enclosed by Constantine; excavations 1939–1949; graffito read "Pétr[os] enì" (Peter is here), with an alternative reading.

  11. Liturgical1969–presentDraft

    General Roman Calendar (Calendarium Romanum, promulgated 1969, as subsequently revised), 20 January: Saints Fabian, Pope and Martyr, and Sebastian, Martyr (optional memorials).

  12. Early source1968Draft

    Pope Paul VI, General Audience, 26 June 1968, closing the Year of Faith; English in L'Osservatore Romano (weekly English edition), 4 July 1968. Online (opens in a new tab)

    Italian: "anche le reliquie di San Pietro sono state identificate in modo che possiamo ritenere convincente"; "Non saranno esaurite con ciò le ricerche, le verifiche, le discussioni e le polemiche." The EWTN English ("in a manner that We cannot but accept as convincing") reads stronger than the original. Contrasts with Pius XII's 1950 announcement.

  13. Early source2026Draft

    Pope Leo XIV, Angelus, Saint Peter's Square, 29 June 2026, Solemnity of the Holy Apostles Peter and Paul. Online (opens in a new tab)

    "Today we celebrate the Solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul, the Patrons of Rome"; later "the patron saints of the Church of Rome."